8 responses to “T-minus 1 month and counting”

  1. Moiety

    Delusions of grandeur; I doubt it. In chemical engineering we did a lot of practical labs for ungraduate courses. Some examples

    Courses and labs for chemistry were not necessarily linked but rather the laboratory practicals were there to cover the standard reactions and procedures.

    Mechanics involved lab and course work on say friction. Instrumentation involved studies into hysteresis and control in both a practical and theoretical sense (i.e. the equations of control theory were shown to have a practical and physical foundation).

    For chemical engineering distillation is a major topic (approximately 2 hours a week over 4 years) so we had to do several lab sessions with several types of columns and of course design them in theory (ultimately). Bernoulli and pressure drop were relatively simple to see in action in the lab but no so on paper. Air humidity and cooling tower design involved running a bench top cooling ‘tower’ to show L/G equations in action. Etc.

  2. Carmen

    It was a mixed bag during my time in college. The courses where the labs followed a central theme definitely were way more effective. For example, my basic electronics class. Lecture work was tied into the labs by building up the circuits discussed that week be it a current source, diff pair, output stage, etc., until we had a full multi-stage amplifier breadboarded. Doing the hands on work in conjunction with the labs definitely helped my understanding of the material. In my opinion, I learned less in the ones where the lecture and lab seemed to be on totally different topics.

  3. gasstationwithoutpumps

    A senior design project should not have much technical content to the lectures—otherwise there is no time for doing a real project. What our senior design class has for “lectures” is instruction on team formation and engineering management and a lot of practice at writing reports and doing presentations. It is assumed that the students have (or can acquire) the technical skills needed for their projects, but have not had opportunities to learn the communication and management skills needed to pull off a real group project.

    There are a few holes in the prior engineering education that have been identified by the instructors over the years, and the students are required to do some library research and present tutorials on these subjects (power supply design and thermal calculations for the EEs, for example).

    A senior design project course should not be like first-year chem, with a lot of new material to be learned and practiced. It should be about making the transition from learning stuff that other people already know to discovering new things (in science) or making new designs (in engineering). Thus lecture should be limited to non-science, non-engineering stuff (Gantt charts, group charters, oral presentation, proposal writing, selecting research topics, lab safety, … ). As much as possible, the students should be presenting material to each other.

    If the projects are individual, not group, then you could probably drop the management stuff and replace it with students presenting proposals and tutorials.

    A good design class requires a lot of time from the professor, but not in lecture prep. The time is spent providing detailed feedback on written drafts (I require full drafts of the final report updated every 2 weeks), meeting individually with students or teams (half an hour per student every week) and hanging around the lab to help students debug their projects.

  4. Advice on teaching senior design classes « Gas station without pumps

    […] response to a post on Engineer Blogs (T-minus 1 month and counting) about a new professor who has been assigned to teach a senior design class, I put together some […]

  5. gasstationwithoutpumps
  6. FrauTech

    Unfortunately some of my labs were structured this way. I chalk it up to it really needing to be two classes (a separate lab and lecture) that cover different but related topics, but for whatever reason they’ve crammed it into one. It’s almost like taking two classes (the learning load and workload are such). That worked for me as a paying student as it meant sort of of a “half off” thing. It worked poorly for students who were on financial aid and had to take a required number of units to qualify and would’ve likely preferred the two classes actually be treated as two classes.

  7. Writing in Style | Engineer Blogs

    […] last few months, I was looking forward to setting up my lab and working on lecture prep for my fall Lab/Project course. Now, granted, most of the writing I’m doing right now involves me and my arch-rival (Word). […]